Feed Reader Search Topic Wavelength
July 14th, 2006
In my search to find a better solution to reading my subscribed feeds in a standalone desktop client, it seems other people are thinking about reading feeds as well.
Online, Offline or Both
Just this morning David at BloggingPro, wrote about his use of feed readers and offers his opinion and habits using online services such as Bloglines and offline clients like FeedDemon. My own experience using most online tools—not just feed readers—is that they are slow and changing settings is often takes two to three times as many steps vs. a standalone application.
Folder and the River
This afternoon, Robert Scoble noted that he prefers the folder to the river as a method for reading posts. This is the way I have been reading feeds this last few months. I had tried browser extensions and then switched to the feed reading support in Thunderbird but became frustrated with a lack of control of my feed appearance.
Cautious Conversion to FeedReader
My search led me to install FeedReader. I am a cautious convert. I had no trouble installing the application but I found that its default display was too small and the contrast was too low. Fortunately, if you know Cascading Style Sheets, changing the display is quite easy using the XSL file.
NewsGator Doesn’t Make it Easy
After a comment from NewsGator regarding my complaint that I was unable to download their reader for the 30-day trial, I successfully downloaded and installed it. Too bad after importing my OPML file from FeedReader, FeedDemon kept coming up with errors. Sorry NewsGator, two failures and you’ve lost me. Seemed like it would be a good application but who has the time to debug commercial software issues. (Jack Brewster: I don’t have an hour to uninstall and reinstall and go through the process of trying to make it work. Maybe I will revisit this soon.
Tags: BloggingPro, Bloglines, FeedDemon, feed readers, rss readers, Robert Scoble, FeedReader, NewsGator
Entry Filed under: Miscellanea
Like this post and want to read more like it? Subscribe Now!
2 Comments Add your own
1. Jules | October 2nd, 2006 at 11:19 am
How does Firefox 2 fit into your reading methods? Apparently it will have a new reader interface. I haven’t read anything about Thunderbird and when (or wheither) it is being upgraded to 2.0 so your comments on either of these would be interesting.
2. jay | October 2nd, 2006 at 12:05 pm
Jules,
I haven’t looked into this at all as I have really found that FeedReader seems to have fit all of what I want out of a feedreader. In addition, I don’t or won’t be migrating to FF2.0 for a while as I require many of the extensions that rely on the current 1.5X base.
I would hope that TBird will have some added functionality over the next while but I don’t think I will ever put news back into an email client again. The main feature I wan’t to see in TBird is outgoing mail filtration. I like to place emails relating to subject directories in their corresponding directories instead of leaving them in the Sent dir. This is a feature that I had experienced on one of my Linux boxes in (I think) Kmail and I really liked it.
So for me the search is over. I have found my ultimate feedreader (which, by the way, is very customizable using the xml and xslt files).
Let me know what you think about FF2.0 when and if you try it.
All the best,
Jay
Leave a Comment
Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed